black hatIn use · 76%Techniques that violate search engine guidelines. The hat metaphor is borrowed from security research and, like most such borrowings, flattens a spectrum into a binary that practitioners then argue about endlessly.
First seen 2004 · Peaked 2017 · Retains 76% of peak
cloakingObsolete · 9%Serving different content to crawlers than to human visitors. A direct policy violation and grounds for removal from the index, because it attacks the assumption that what a search engine indexes is what a reader receives.
First seen 2004 · Peaked 2004 · Retains 9% of peak
doorway pagesObsolete · 10%Pages built to rank for a query and funnel visitors elsewhere, offering nothing themselves. The tactic survives as mass-generated location pages, which is why the modern policy language targets scaled content abuse rather than the original term.
First seen 2004 · Peaked 2004 · Retains 10% of peak
invisible textObsolete · 0%Keywords hidden from readers but visible to crawlers — classically white text on a white background. The technique described in Wikipedia’s 2002 spamdexing article, and the crudest form of keyword stuffing.
First seen 2005 · Peaked 2005 · Retains 0% of peak
keyword stuffingObsolete · 21%Loading a page with repeated keywords to force relevance. Among the oldest recognised abuses, explicitly named in search engine spam policies, and reliably counterproductive since at least the mid-2000s.
First seen 2005 · Peaked 2005 · Retains 21% of peak
link farmObsolete · 22%A group of sites created solely to link to each other and inflate apparent authority. One of the earliest recognised link schemes, and among the first things search engines learned to detect and penalise.
First seen 2004 · Peaked 2007 · Retains 22% of peak
paid inclusionFading · 56%Paying a search engine to index or list a page. Once an openly sold product — Yahoo and others ran formal programmes — and now essentially extinct in general web search, which is why the term has all but vanished.
First seen 2004 · Peaked 2005 · Retains 56% of peak
paid linksFading · 59%Links bought for ranking rather than traffic. A direct violation of search engine guidelines unless disclosed with rel="sponsored", and the reason the nofollow attribute family exists at all.
First seen 2007 · Peaked 2007 · Retains 59% of peak
reciprocal linksFading · 35%A mutual exchange — you link to me, I link to you. Common enough in the early 2000s to have dedicated directories and software; now understood as a scheme when done at scale, and simply unremarkable when it happens naturally.
First seen 2005 · Peaked 2007 · Retains 35% of peak
white hatFading · 34%Techniques that comply with search engine guidelines. Defined entirely by its opposite, which is why the term is far less useful than it sounds — it describes an absence of misconduct rather than a method.
First seen 2004 · Peaked 2006 · Retains 34% of peak
Networked publishing platforms. The single most frequent term in our corpus by an order of magnitude — not because it is an SEO technique, but because it reshaped what the surrounding articles were about.
First seen 2006 · Peaked 2022 · Retains 76% of peak